coffee, hiking and high altitudes

This morning, our entire group headed to the local coffee cooperative, CEPCO,  in Oaxaca. Five leaders from the organization spoke to our group. The cooperative covers seven regions in the state and has about 4000 members who belong to 40 different organizations. The member farms are mostly small producers who farm 2-2.5 hectares, with a small handful running farms that have 5 hectares.  CEPCO is a member of a national coffee organization, but based on what I heard this morning,  it is run independently.

The cooperative serves the producers in many ways, with the end goal of improving farmer income. One critical aspect was through the formation of a credit union for the producers, so they could borrow money to finance their coffee crops.  Traditional forms of credit are not available to the small producers because they lack sufficient collateral (globally, including the US, access to credit is one of the biggest problems small-scale producers face).

Four to five years ago, the cooperative started producing coffee under an organic production system (I bought 1/2 kilo this morning), in order to add more value to the farmers’ crops.  The cooperative provides technical assistance and training to farmers to ensure they follow organic regulations.

About 80 percent of the harvest is exported (EU, US and Canada); the export markets provide the largest returns to farmers.

Providing a high quality product that meets the requirements for export markets in a key goal (crucially tied to the improving farmer income goal) of the group. Thus, the cooperative is involved in all stages of production and processing, including grading, sorting, and packaging.

Three of us are sick today (including me!) and came back to the hotel and the rest of the class headed to one of the cooperative’s coffee plantations. The five hour bus ride was not something the three of us could face today. Unfortunately, the construction in the hotel is keeping me awake, but also giving me the time to catch up on what we’ve been doing. So here are the rest of the details on yesterday’s hike:

As we walked through the woods, we saw several farmers working on different fields. One was plowing his cornfield, using a plow drawn by a team of oxen.

IMG_2154We saw burros standing by the fields, waiting to carry the hand harvested corn (we were unable to see the harvesting from the trail). We also saw several farmers working in their fields, preparing the soil. Corn planting time is just around the corner: February and March.

Despite the beauty of the fields and the meticulous care that was obvious to us, the subsistence farmers are unable to make a living from their fields (our guide reported that to us).

IMG_2152Given the poverty of the people living in the area, I felt a little guilty enjoying the natural beauty surrounding us as we hiked. The mountains of Oaxaca are exquisitely lovely.

The end of our hike was an ascent of 365 feet over less than one mile. Several students were unhappy, and honestly, I was huffing and puffing as I walked up that stretch (but I still loved it!). When we reached the top, I remarked to the few students within earshot: imagine how it must be to harvest your food (that you bring to market to seel) and then to strap it to a burro, and walk home or to market, up steep hills.

Lo and behold, as soon as I uttered those words, an indigenous farmer (a woman named Cecile) walked up with her burrow, loaded with three bags full of 185 bunches of watercress that she was taking home to wash.   She sells the bunches in the market for 2 pesos each; our translator bought a bunch and gave her 5 pesos.  The day in the mountains – first at Monte Alban and then in the woods of Benito Juarez – was spectacular.  I am sorry that I missing the coffee plantation, but I expect a report complete with photos tomorrow.

IMG_2169 - Version 2

Posted in Food studies, Oaxaca, organic food | Leave a comment

monte alban and hiking in benito juarez

Today was a long day and tomorrow will be as well.  Thus I will be short in my posting, since it is 10 pm and our departure is set for 8 am tomorrow morning.

This morning started with a visit to Monte Alban. This is a Zapoteck ruin that remains relatively untouched by the Spaniards, unlike the site at Mitla. There is a beautiful and logical symmetry about Monte Alban, and in addition to the scientific way the village was created (in harmony with the cycles of the sun and the moon), the setting is incredibly beautiful. The Mexican Indians were truly an innovative group.

IMG_2109 IMG_2119We left Monte Alban, dropped off Christine (whose hip was aching) and headed to Benito Juarez to hike through the mountains. First of all, we drove for about 40 km up an unpaved road, that winded back and forth and had no rails on the edge. Further, the road was barely wide enough for 2 cars, and clearly a bus and a car would not be able to drive by each other. So we were all a bit nervous! And if that was not enough to keep us interested, the bus came upon a herd of cows and a cow hand that were blocking our way.

IMG_2129(This is the view from the front window of the bus). We finally made it to the starting point for our hike:

IMG_2130We hired a local guide, who took us on a 5 mile hike through the forest. We first headed down about 800 feet. The group was incredibly good spirited – a few of us (including me and Christy) are experienced hikers and love the outdoors. Some others are clearly city folk, and they did their best to maintain a great attitude (and that includes our UPEAP colleague, Octavio!).

IMG_2136I have hiked in many places around the world, but this hike was one of the most unique and special for many reasons. We first walked along the unpaved road, and saw subsistence farms (you know, the ones you read about!). The farmland and the vistas are breathtakingly beautiful. The elevation was about 10,000 feet, so we had an exquisite view of the mountains and valleys around us. Interspersed among the subsistence farms are greenhouses (think big hoop houses) for growing watercress, and houses of rich people (this is one). Animals are abundant: donkeys, burros, and sheep. It was hard not to be happy to be alive.

We marched off the path into the woods:

IMG_2146I will finish talking about our hike tomorrow. My computer battery (and my personal battery) is just about dead. The hotel will be turning off the internet at any moment!

Posted in Food studies, Oaxaca | Leave a comment

permaculture, mitla, and mezcal

Our day started with a trip to Tierra del Sol, a permaculture farm and sustainable living center in Oaxaca. The day started out with a bit of a snarl, when the bus got stuck under the branches of big trees and the driver was afraid that the ac would be destroyed. So we jumped off the bus and walked the remaining distance to the farm.

IMG_2085 IMG_2083IMG_2087Peter Bloom (aka Pedro), a transplant from Philadelphia to Oaxaca, gave us a tour of the farm. He spoke about the farm’s mission of using a bio-intensive farming method to feed the people living on the farm. The food production area consists of of raised beds filled with compost, and there was a 4 part crop rotation system. The first set of crops planted are those using lots of nutrients from the soil (plants that bear fruit); the second draws a smaller amount of nutrients from soil (leafy greens); the third rotation consists of tubers, which do not use any nutrients from the soil; and the fourth rotation includes crops that add nutrients back to the soil (legumes).  The complete cycle of the four plants takes about 9 – 12 months, on average. The three hours at Tierra del Sol passed really quickly, and it was time for us to leave to take a tour of Mitla.

The final stop of the day was a small scale mezcal production site right by Mitla (just a short walk away).  This was a family owned business – they harvested maguey leaves (this is the Mexican all purpose plant) and cooked them in a big pit for 3 days, and then let them cool for 3 more days.

IMG_1075 IMG_1073The leaves are then placed in a different pit, where a horse walks in circles, pulling stones that break up the leaves. Then the leaves ferment in tanks, and then the fermented juice of the leaves is distilled. The product is aged in oak barrels for different lengths of time, and the longer the mezcal is aged, the better is the drink.  Most of us bought at least one bottle of mezcal to bring home to our friends and family.

Tomorrow is a trip to Mont Albans, and then a hike in mountains near Benito Juarez.

 

 

Posted in agriculture, Food studies, Oaxaca, permaculture | 1 Comment

in Oaxaca

We set out right on time this morning – a gigantic bus picked us up at 9 am. After loading our bags, we headed first to El Calvario, which is the largest egg producer in Latin America. More details on that tomorrow.

We had a class discussion about what we’ve seen over the past few days. The trip has been intense – we have seen many parts of the Mexican food system. For many of us, the concept of treating an animal like a “crop” was hard to swallow. We talked about the many ways that traditional Mexican food has both been altered by globalization and/or industrialization, and how it has remained true. Several examples were pointed out: the spicy snacks and desserts, mechanization in tortillas, and the celebration of festivals. We also fleshed out some differences and similarities between the Mexican and US food system (it is late right now, so I won’t add detail tonight).

We drove for three more hours and then arrived in Oaxaca. The landscape between Puebla and Oaxaca is beautiful, and is full of rocky mountains and valleys.

We are staying in a former convent: Casa Antica. It is quite noisy here, and there is an active night life. Christy was full of glee as she watched a truck pumping flour (think of a pumper fire truck and replace the water with flour) into the bakery. I have never seen her so excited.

Many of the students are out enjoying a Friday night in Oaxaca.

 

Posted in Food studies, Oaxaca | Leave a comment

goodbye Puebla, tomorrow we head to Oaxaca

Today was a great day.  First a lecture on Mexican food by a cultural anthropologist, and then 3 free hours! While I love being busy, I do appreciate a little downtime (and we are all getting a little tired). Then the afternoon was spent in the Gastronomic Institute of UPAEP, where we had a “culinary experience.” We cooked a Mexican meal, under the direction of the chef. We made tortillas, using a small tortilla press and a nonstick pan. We cooked corn smut, which is a plant fungus, in onions and corn oil. We separated the strings of queso Oaxaca, which looked like a lot of work for those who performed that task.  Others made different kinds of salsa from different combinations of dried peppers, cheese, tomatillas and garlic. We soaked chia seeds, cut lemons, and made a lemon water. The chef gave general guidance, and the fabulous cooks in the class made improvements on his suggestions.

IMG_1053 IMG_1056 IMG_1049To the left, Anna has some trouble with the tortilla press; next I am enjoying corn smut preparations; and Christine is pressing tortillas.

IMG_1061 IMG_1063 IMG_1064 IMG_1060Starting from the left, Jessica and Kaitlin are cleaning; Melissa, Christine and Christy are doing something; and Matt, Anita, and Selina are enjoying themselves. To the left Eric, Siobhan and Amy are also cooking different parts of the meal.

The day ended with a “Mexican event,” which was a surprise hosted by our hosts, Octavio and Armando. The first act was a Mariacchi band (the lead singer was a rather large man who could really move and sing!) Next a dancing group performed traditional Mexican dances, where the women wore colorful, full, flowing dresses, and the men wore sombreros and pants with metallic buttons all the way down the outer seam. They invited several of our students to the stage, as well as the incoming students from the US who were planning to spend a semester studying at their university. Sadly, I did not bring my camera to the surprise event, so I have no photos to share.

Tomorrow – the headquarters of an egg farm and then Oaxaca! Phase 2 of our trip is near, and we are all ready to move on.

 

 

 

Posted in Food studies, Puebla | Leave a comment

food systems, food culture and barbacoa

Until this morning, I incorrectly thought that barbocoa was cooked goat meat, but actually it is a method of cooking.  Traditionally, barbocoa is meat that is cooked in a pit dug into the earth, and covered with mud. The modern adaptation is a brick oven that can be covered with a mat and mud. This morning, we drove about 1 1/2 hours to a hacienda in Huamantla for traditional barbacoa (I am geographically challenged, so I can’t say which direction with certainty, but I think it was east). There is a long history to the hacienda, elements of which include: this is the region where Cortes spent time and also where sheep and lamb meat were introduced by the Spanish into the Mexican cuisine. Our hosts spent quite a long time talking about the history of their hacienda and the region.

IMG_2033

IMG_2032
IMG_2025 IMG_2018

 

 

 

The hacienda is beautiful and very very old, and is inhabited by Don Pepe and his family. Don Pepe is famous for his barbocoa (see this recipe), where the meat is cooked on top  of a large pot of soup (and I mean large). The cover of the soup pot has large holes, like a colander, which allows the steam from the soup to add a subtle flavor to the meat.

We also watched Don Pepe cut a lamb carcass into pieces:
IMG_2038

And Siobhan carried a leg and Anita carried the testicles over to the pot:
IMG_2039

IMG_2040

 

 

Which looked like this, once it was all together and in the pit (you might recognize the large leaves from the pulque making:
IMG_2042
While the meat was cooking for almost four hours, we watched two men slaughter and skin a 6 month old lamb:
IMG_2048
I watched every single step of the process, which I found extremely disturbing. I might have the process less shocking if we had given thanks to the animal, or said something prior to tying its legs. But the workers were unceremonious, and methodically and quickly went about their task. I am a vegetarian and after today, I intend to remain that way.

After a tour of the town, which included the puppet museum and city hall, we witnessed a mock bull fight (meaning no bulls were killed). The bull was a 2 year old cow, and she was a female.  Three students (Melissa, Erik, and Siobhan), one a time, were in the ring with the matadors and the bull.
IMG_2069

IMG_2075

IMG_2077

Today was a long day, which ended by eating an amiable meal together (of the lamb and soup cooked in the pit). Feeling full of the traditions of Mexico, with barbacoa, eating in a hacienda, watching an animal being slaughtered using the old methods, and the bull fight, we headed to the bus and back to Puebla.

IMG_2081

Posted in agriculture, Food studies, Puebla | Leave a comment

day 7 in Puebla

Meat, meat, meat. That was the day’s theme. The other aspect made very clear is how globalized our markets are.

The first stop of the day was an industrial pig farm, RYC, where we were given a wonderful tour by several members of the farm’s staff.   The farm’s operation covers nearly all stages of production, starting from mixing feed (from mostly purchased inputs) on the farm and continuing to fattening the pig for market. In between, the female pigs are inseminated from pig semen (from Canada, if I am remembering correctly).  Each stage of the operation takes place in different, large barns.

A pig is pregnant for almost exactly 115 days, with just 2% not exactly hitting this timing. The pregnancy ward, so to speak, is a large barn full of gestational crates. These structures make it impossible for the pig to move, so that all food (energy) is passed to the fetal pigs. The average litter size on the farm is about 12 pigs; the “natural” rate is about 8 pigs, but modern breeding methods have increased the litter size.

IMG_2002 IMG_2001For animal welfare reasons, gestational crates are illegal in Europe (but not in the US). Mexico is heading in that direction, and our host informed us that they are preparing for the day when their barns will be retrofit.  The crates will be tossed. The feeding systems will have to be adapted, as will the feed the pigs receive. The costs will be high, and not all operations will be able to financially survive the shift to the upcoming new animal welfare standards. The remaining operations, however, will be better off since they will face reduced domestic competition.

About 10 days before the pigs are expected to give birth, they are moved to farrowing crates. The small pigs are really cute. The farrowing crates are slightly larger than the gestational crates, and again are designed for maximum feed conversion (the technical term used to describe the process of converting feed into animal body weight).

IMG_1998 IMG_2000

The pigs are weaned at 21 days. Several workers scoop up the baby pigs and take them to yet another barn. For two days, the pigs fight as a pecking order is established. The pigs in this area are active and playful, and were running back and forth (their hooves made a tapping sound as they scampered across the plastic flooring).  Again, they were delightful creatures, and probably at their cutest in this part of the process.

IMG_2009The next phase, at about 70 days of life, was the finishing room where the pigs spend the next 100 days. At this point, they really smell and few of us had the stamina to stand close to the barn (one student escaped to the bus, in fact). Honestly, they are not so cute when they are this large. And did I mention the smell?

The farm is clearly an industrial farm. And this farm would fit the USDA definition of a very large farm, which is more than 5,000 head or more at peak (this farm had over 40,000 pigs the day we visited). The farming methods are highly scientific: our hosts were clearly smart and informed about all aspects of pig farming (and sheep farming, which took place on the same farm; thisIMG_2007 is possible because sheep and pigs don’t experience the same diseases). The manager is a vet, and 6 other vets are on staff. Every aspect of the operation is well managed. Safety standards (in terms of food safety and animal health) are important, as is the cost of production. In the future, they hope to export their pork products to Asia, as their business expands.

From a environmental perspective, the most impressive aspect of this operation is the biodigester, which converts the manure to electricity. The manure is captured under the barns (in large lagoons), and then goes through an aneorobic process and is converted to biogas. The biogas is then used to generate electricity. The biodigester has reduced the electricity costs from 200,000 pesos a month to 0. Yes, that is zero. The manure generates all the electricity this farm uses. I meant to ask if they were able to sell any electricity back to the grid, but didn’t have a chance (meaning that I felt I was asking too many questions).  The equipment is costly, but the government subsidized the costs. The biodigester takes care of the largest problem of industrial livestock operations – what to do with the large amounts of waste generated. The biodigester is an elegant solution to this problem, and also addresses other problems related to energy use.

We next visited the RYC store, and then the meatpacking plant. Three things struck me about the meatpacking plant: one is use of “by products” of perfectly good food produced in the US, yet not eaten by US consumers. We saw a giant (and I mean giant) vat of turkey legs. Two, when RYC needs additional “raw materials” for their processing plant, they buy from the US market strictly because of the higher food safety standards. Three, despite higher land, labor and regulatory costs, RYC found it less costly to reach the US market by building a plant in San Antonio rather than shipping finished product from Mexico.

Most of us found the day intense – few had been to an industrial farm before, and even I had never visited a meatpacking plant.  That said, I found the day incredible. We haven’t yet had our class discussion of the day (that is slated for tomorrow), but the bits of conversation I have heard suggest this was an eye-opening day for all of us.

Every one of us jumped right into the shower when we returned to the hotel; there was very little chit chatting in the lobby. I washed my clothes in the shower, as did a few others. I am glad to have the smell of manure and the smell of ham (from the meatpacking plant) out of my clothes and hair.

Today’s plan: barbacoa. More to come. Hasta la vista.

 

 

Posted in animal welfare, Food studies, food system, Puebla, Uncategorized | Leave a comment

more about day 6 in Puebla

Our final speaker of the day yesterday, Dr Sandra Solis, discussed the anti-poverty programs in Mexico. She began with a historical overview of these programs, which change each six years (with the president). From the outside, the programs follow a reasonable logic: generally speaking, people living in poverty and deep poverty are given cash transfers for food. In more recent years, the cash transfers are linked to medical care (with different levels of care required for children, pregnant women, and other groups), attendance at nutritional lectures, and school attendance. Mothers receive a higher cash transfer when their daughters attend school. Specific rules dictate how many medical appointments can be missed or how much school can be missed before the cash transfers are revoked.

However, according to Dr Solis, these programs have not been successful. The most recent program was evaluated by an independent group, and the results were not promising: the number of people in poverty had increased between 2008 and 2010.  Since her lecture was translated into English by Juan (our tour’s translator), I missed some of the finer points of her lecture. Without additional research, I have no way of knowing whether the percent of the population living in poverty had also risen.  Also, the global recession occurred during that time period, which caused a large rise in US unemployment. Many migrant workers returned to Mexico from the US during this period. Given the tight linkages between the US and Mexico, it is likely that the Mexicans were also worse off during this time period. Thus it is unclear whether the anti-poverty programs had at least partially offset the effect of the recession. That type of analysis is typically done by economists, and not by public health researchers, and so when I get a chance, I will take a look in the economics literature to see what I can find.

That said, after hearing Dr. Solis speak, I do not feel hopeful. In any country, the problems of poverty and opportunity are linked. The job opportunities are so limited here, that even with slowly increasing educational levels, people are unable to obtain jobs. And with rapid population growth, the Mexican economy faces even more pressures in terms of providing good jobs for workers. However, the FT reports a very low unemployment rate in Mexico (4.7 percent in 2012), but this statistic can be misleading. The unemployment rate only reflects the percent of the labor force, not working age people, that are not working.  About 11 million people (in 2006; about 28 percent of those working) were employed in the “informal labor market,” and they are excluded from the unemployment statistic calculation. The informal status of their jobs means they pay no taxes and receive no health care benefits. Further, they won’t be eligible for social security when they are old. (cite: Tapia, Daniel, and Carlos Marquez Padilla. “The informal economy in Mexico: an alternative labor market.” Voices of Mexico (2006).)

Through conversations with people here, I learned that only 25 percent of the population pays taxes (due to their employment status as either unemployed, indigenous, or working in the informal sector). It seems the amount of tax revenue collected is probably not sufficient to support the social needs of the people in this country, where the social needs are health care, adequate food and nutrition, and support of the aging population (which is increasing). As I said in an earlier post, the poverty rate in Mexico hovers at around 50 percent of the population.

On the positive side of the Mexican anti-poverty is the growth in educating girls. One well-known tremendous benefit is that women with more education have fewer babies, and this effect has been observed around the globe. The Economist reports that the births in Mexico have declined from 7 babies per woman (in the 1960s) to around 2 in (approximately) 2010.

We haven’t really scratched the surface of the problems related to poverty in Mexico, but a new day beckons. Off to the meatpacking plant….so there is more to come later!

Posted in Food studies, nutrition and health, public health, Puebla | 2 Comments

today it feels like

we worked for two days in Puebla. I am starting to lose count! The day was loooong – we left our hotel at 8 am and some, but not all, of us returned to the hotel around 8:30 pm. The rest are still out playing.

A lot happened today. First, we attended a Rosca de Reyes celebration at the University (UPEAP). The university is a private, Catholic school, and the president told us that these celebrations were important because people need to remember their traditions while becoming educated. He also gave a very big hello to the NYU class — this is the 5th or 6th year this course has been in Puebla at this time of year (the class was designed by my colleague Amy Bentley). Again, we had great fortune in that Anna was the one to find the baby (ok crazy but true — the rosca de reyes were from Costco!)

Next, M en C. Lucero Morales Cano gave us a lecture on the history of Mexican cuisine. She spoke about the influence the Spanish had on the traditional Mexican food, and the importance of weather, seasons, and production (or harvest) in the Mexican diet. There were festivals that were related to death and birth. In today’s world, the connection to the harvest and cycles of nature remain in the rural areas, but are largely lost in the urban centers. She also spoke about the importance of women in passing along traditional recipes, and told us how women hold the knowledge of cooking and cuisine (this theme is mentioned by everyone we meet).

After a short bus ride, we had a tour of a spectacularly modern food store – Mega. This store is the most incredible food store I have been in. The produce manager and the meat manager took us on a tour of the store (btw, they were not super impressed with the NYU pen I gave as a thank you gift!). The price labels on the shelf are electronic! There is a radio system, and in the middle of the night prices are updated. They spent about 9 mill US dollars on this, and it will have paid for itself in just 6 months. Other things we saw: chicken feet! huge produce section! fresh baked bread! costco sized packages in one section! organic food! prepared foods! (excuse my prolific use of exclamation marks – supermarkets are exciting, plus I am a bit punchy right now). They also sell packages of pork fat (no exclamation mark here).

IMG_1945

IMG_1949

IMG_1920

IMG_1950

 

 

 

 

 

After our visit to the food store, we went to Cholula, and had a tour of the museum and pyramid. Well….SOME of us had a tour. I went into the restroom and when I came out, the group was gone (and no where to be found). After about 30 minutes, our UPEAP host Octavio came back for me. Apparently, I was the first professor that he lost.
IMG_1975

IMG_1978

IMG_1988

 

 

 

Then, to make matters even worse, when we finished touring the museum, the gate appeared to be locked (with us inside). Octavio, who was probably really happy to go home this evening, went in search of assistance. In the meantime, a cleaning woman came up to us, and laughed as she pushed the gate wide open. Boy. We were not pleased with our failure to test the gate.

IMG_1990

 

 

This was not the end of our day – Dr. Sandra Solis lectured us on Mexican anti-poverty programs, but frankly, I am too tired to write about that now. Buenas noches!

Posted in Food studies, Uncategorized | Leave a comment

day 5 in Puebla

Today – Three Kings Day and Sunday – was a day off for the class. After sleeping in, most people walked around Puebla for the early part of the day. This city doesn’t wake up early on Sunday morning.

We had a class meeting at 5, at an excellent coffee shop (Zaranda Cafe), where I had my first espresso of the trip. Oh that made me very happy! I do miss my morning espresso (I think the others do as well). We began a discussion of competing explanations for why the Mexican diet consists of both traditional foods and industrial foods (largely sold in food stores that entered the country after NAFTA), even though obesity is a serious problem in the country. We discussed several factors, some of which were poverty, the social comfort with a heavier body, land values, food production, the Mexican strong identification with their food, and the Mexican tradition of hopefulness and optimism. On the walk back to the hotel, Christy (the TA for the course) and I both agreed that our knowledge of Mexican culture was not deep enough to fully understand this topic.

People headed their separate ways for dinner tonight; seven of us went to Christy’s favorite torta and churros restaurant. We ate cemitas (mine was a cemitas des quesillo, with avocado, and was on seeded roll that looked like my dad’s favorite sandwich roll from his local bakery). This simple meal was my favorite, to date (that made Christy laugh a little).
IMG_1033

IMG_1034

Then, Jessica had a second dessert (post churros, that is!) of blue and yellow corn kernals, topped with a bit of mayo, chili pepper (I think), cheese and lime. Yum.

IMG_1035

That’s all for today. We have a long day tomorrow.

Posted in Food studies | Leave a comment